A Word About “The Lives of Others” – A Movie Review

The 2006 German film, The Lives of Others, successfully does what today’s movie critics declined to mention in their reviews:  it condemns Communism.  Too, it exposes a government, East German in 1984, that is slowly getting weary of Communism, whether the death throes are there or not.  A Stasi member called Wiesler (Ulrich Muhe) realizes just how spiritually draining the GDR is.  Although the change which comes over him is insufficiently believable, Wiesler seems to be humanized by three things:  music, some poetry by Brecht, and–the lives of others, viz. the people he is spying on.  One of them is the victim of a Commie’s sexual harassment. 

Directed and written by Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck, The Lives of Others is absorbing and nicely plotted.  It’s rated R because actress Martina Gedeck has her breast squeezed (by a man) and then exposed.  But it isn’t gratuitous.

(The film is in German with English subtitles.) 

Cover of "The Lives of Others"

Cover of The Lives of Others

The Little-Seen Failure, “Before the Rains” – A Movie Review

The Merchant Ivory film, Before the Rains (2007), is a wonderland of rich scenery.  Set in India, it was photographed by its director, Santosh Sivan.  Too bad a second-rate story, with the character of a British colonialist in 1937 given short shrift, wrecks the enterprise.  In fact, a whole lotta hogwash is here.

Linus Roache supplies a little too much on-the-surface acting as the colonialist, but is passable.  Rahul Bose is largely uninteresting as an Indian right-hand man.  The women, Nandita Das and Jennifer Ehle, however, have their hearts in it and never make a false move.  Put another way, no surface stuff.  If you’re drawn at all to this film, see it for these two performances.

Before the Rains

Image via Wikipedia

Perrotta and His Sudden Departure: “The Leftovers” – A Book Review

Tom Perrotta at the 2007 Texas Book Festival, ...

Image via Wikipedia

In the non-naturalistic The Leftovers (2011), Tom Perrotta’s new novel, millions of people have disappeared from the earth in a Rapture-like phenomenon, and a great many were not Christians.  It was a “random harvest” and most of Perrotta’s attention is fixed on what has ensued in the U.S. suburbs now that this inexplicable tragedy has occurred.  At bottom the Sudden Departure, as it is called, is simply the next bad thing to happen after such events as 9/11, Hurricane Katrina, the Japanese tsunami, etc.; the novel subtly presents it as such.

A spellbinding fact is that sundry religious cults have arisen, winning such converts as the wife (Laurie) and son (Tom) of Kevin Garvey, the mayor of a town called Mapleton.  The cult that has lured in Laurie is the Guilty Remnant, a bizarre religion whose adherents wear white, almost never speak, and routinely smoke cigarettes.  Perrotta’s point here may well be this:  To slightly alter something G.K. Chesterton said, when people stop believing in the traditional God, they start believing in anything.  False gods are ubiquitous, notwithstanding there is in the book a ruined minister, Max Jamison, who does not even turn to a false god.  He fails to accept that a non-traditional event like the random (but was it random?) Sudden Departure could have come from the true Deity.

One might suspect The Leftovers of being depressing, but it isn’t.  It’s merely serious as well as lively, wry and humane.  Though it’s been called satirical, for the most part that isn’t true.

The photo is of Tom Perrotta.  

A Young Man’s Cancer in “50/50” – A Movie Review

The screenplay for 50/50 was penned by one Will Reiser and is based on Reiser’s own bout with spinal cancer.  A tragic comedy as opposed to a comic tragedy, it stars Joseph Gordon-Leavitt as the young, dutiful suburbanite with a tumor on his spine.

The most interesting thing about the film is how it exhibits the ways in which people react to and deal with Adam’s (Gordon-Leavitt’s) cancer.  His girlfriend (Bryce Dallas Howard) starts behaving disgracefully.  Adam’s close buddy Kyle (Seth Rogen) wants Adam to get laid–and also uses him to attract women.  But, in addition, he always sticks by him.  Adam himself reacts to the disease by smoking marijuana.  Welcome to the Western world and its young people.

Directed by Jonathan Levine, 50/50 is mildly funny–I don’t consider it hilarious, as some have claimed–and occasionally packs a punch (as when Adam begins to act irrationally behind the wheel of Kyle’s car).  It’s also rather slight, though.  Really, it’s a little less enjoyable than some of today’s lauded TV series such as Breaking Bad, Mad Men, Big Love and Sons of Anarchy.  TV writers are giving motion picture writers a run for their money, notwithstanding 50/50 IS perfectly watchable.

I Salute You, Sir: “Captain America” – A Movie Review

Captain America Comics#1 (March 1941). Cover a...

Image via Wikipedia

In Joe Johnston’s comic-book movie, Captain America: The First Avenger (2011), a brave but physically puny Steve Rogers (Chris Evans) becomes, via a serum, a stunningly strong Captain America, eager to defeat a powerful Third Reich psychopath with a red skull (Hugo Weaving).  The time is the 1940s.

There is little chemistry between Evans and British actress Haley Atwell, and the film doesn’t have the guts to be more American than international (it is meant for an international audience), but it’s a captivating, sometimes witty, adventure-fantasy all the same.  It’s visually better than anything George Lucas did–the retro production design can be transporting but is never overdone–and the action can be imaginative.  On the other hand, to me the action eventually gets tiresome in a way it doesn’t in 2010’s Kick-Ass. 

Not great, this picture, but still fun.  And, yes, it is patriotic, despite the international dramatis personae.